Our Insights

When to Bring in a DEI and Workplace Culture Consultant: A Guide for HR Decision-Makers

Creating a diverse, equitable, and inclusive workplace is not a box to check but an ongoing commitment that requires intention, skill, and accountability. Many HR teams and leaders are working hard to advance this commitment, but even with the best intentions, internal DEI and workplace culture initiatives can fall short. Knowing when to bring in a DEI and workplace culture consultant can save time, increase impact, and help you create meaningful, lasting change.

Here is a practical guide for HR decision-makers on when and how to partner with a consultant to advance your DEI and workplace culture goals.

Signs Your Internal DEI Efforts Need Support

Even the most dedicated HR teams may reach a point where they need external expertise. Here are common signs your organization may benefit from bringing in a DEI and workplace culture consultant:

• Stalled Progress: You have launched DEI initiatives (committees, policies, training), but there’s little measurable change in representation, culture, or employee experiences.
• Survey Fatigue with Little Action: Engagement or DEI survey data is collected but there’s a struggle to analyze, prioritize, and implement meaningful action based on findings.
• Employee Feedback Indicates Deeper Issues: Persistent concerns about microaggressions, harassment and discrimination, psychological safety, or inequities in promotions, pay, or opportunities, despite internal efforts.
• High Employee Turnover: Challenges with retaining staff, and exit feedback suggests that culture, inclusion, and belonging may be contributing factors.
• Leadership Alignment is Lacking: Senior leaders may support DEI in principle but struggle to effectively connect it to organizational goals, model inclusive day-to-day behaviours, or prioritize DEI strategically.
• Limited Capacity or Expertise: HR teams and DEI committees are often balancing many competing priorities, making it challenging to consistently dedicate the specialized time and focus that meaningful DEI work requires.
• Preparing for Growth or Change: Mergers, leadership transitions, rapid growth or downsizing, are times when DEI and workplace culture efforts risk being deprioritized unless intentionally integrated.

If your organization is experiencing these challenges, a DEI and workplace culture consultant can help you move from intention to action with clarity and confidence.

What Workplace Culture Consultants Actually Do (and Don’t Do)

There’s a misconception that consultants come in to “fix” a culture, but that’s not accurate. Here’s what a DEI and workplace culture consultant actually does:

• Provides an External, Objective Lens: Consultants can identify patterns and hidden biases in your organization that may be difficult to notice internally due to familiarity or internal politics.
• Conducts Assessments: Through targeted surveys, focus groups, interviews, and policies/processes reviews, consultants gather and analyze data to uncover gaps, strengths, and opportunities.
• Builds a Roadmap: Consultants translate findings into a clear, actionable DEI and culture strategy aligned with your organizational goals, helping you determine the most effective path to building a more diverse and equitable workplace.
• Mediates Conflict: Consultants can support the resolution of interpersonal and team conflicts through a DEI lens, helping teams navigate complex issues with care and accountability.
• Facilitates Training and Dialogue: They deliver tailored, interactive training and workshops to build competencies in inclusive leadership, psychological safety, and equity-based practices.
• Collaborates with HR on Inclusive Policies and Practices: Consultants partner with you to implement unbiased practices and review policies and processes using an intersectional framework that considers how gender identity, race, disability, and other identities intersect with systems of power. This includes reviewing and advising on:
  • Respectful Workplace Policies
  • Accommodations and Flexible Work Policies
  • Compensation & Benefits
  • Talent Acquisition
• Supports Change Management: Consultants help integrate DEI into systems, structures, and behaviours rather than one-off initiatives.
• Offers Accountability: By partnering with leaders and HR teams, consultants can help track progress and adjust strategies as needed.

What consultants don’t do:

• They don’t replace leadership accountability for culture. Leaders still need to model and drive the changes internally.
• They don’t offer quick fix solutions. Sustainable culture change takes commitment over time.
• They don’t impose a one-size-fits-all approach. Effective consultants adapt to your unique context, workforce, and goals.

Evaluating Workplace Culture Consulting Services: What HR Should Look For

Choosing the right DEI and workplace culture consultant is crucial for ensuring your investment translates into meaningful, sustainable change. Here’s what HR decision-makers should consider:

1. Experience and Expertise: Look for consultants with a proven track record in advancing DEI and workplace culture within contexts similar to yours (e.g., sector, organization size, stage of DEI maturity). They should demonstrate a strong understanding of DEI principles, systemic inequities, bias, and strategies for fostering inclusive environments, and be well-versed in current trends and research.
2. Evidence-Based Approaches: Ask about their methods and frameworks, and how they ensure strategies are grounded in research and best practices, rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
3. Customization: Effective consultants tailor assessments, recommendations, and training to align with your organization’s mission, values, and culture while addressing your unique challenges and opportunities.
4. Facilitation Skills: Effective consultants are skilled listeners who can navigate sensitive conversations with care while making complex topics understandable. They should be able to deliver engaging, accessible training and workshops that foster psychological safety and encourage open dialogue.
5. Clear Deliverables: Ensure there is clarity on what you will receive, such as final reports, facilitated sessions, policy reviews, and implementation support, and how progress will be measured throughout the engagement.
6. Capacity Building: Rather than creating dependency, strong consultants empower your leaders and teams to sustain DEI and culture work internally, embedding DEI into systems, behaviours, and leadership practices for the long term.
7. Alignment with Goals: Whether your priorities are equitable hiring, psychological safety, leadership accountability, policy reviews, or employee engagement, ensure your consultant’s services align with your organizational goals to drive targeted, meaningful results.
8. Change Management: Advancing DEI often involves cultural and systemic transformation. Seek consultants with expertise in guiding organizations through change, who can engage and influence leadership to drive sustainable progress.

Real Results: Metrics That Matter in Workplace Culture Consulting

One of the biggest concerns HR leaders have is whether investing in DEI and workplace culture consulting will generate tangible outcomes. While results can look different across organizations, here are key metrics that matter:

• Representation: Changes in the diversity of your workforce, especially in leadership and decision-making roles.
• Employee Experience: Improvements in feelings of belonging, psychological safety, and perceptions of fairness (often measured through engagement or pulse surveys).
• Equity in Processes: Increased transparency and fairness in hiring, promotions, pay, and performance evaluations.
• Retention and Advancement: Improved retention and advancement of equity-deserving groups within your organization.
• Leadership Engagement: Observable behaviours from leaders demonstrating commitment to DEI, such as sponsorship, participation in training, and inclusive practices.
• Policy and System Changes: Adoption of equitable policies, integration of DEI into strategic plans, and changes to systems that perpetuate inequity.
• Feedback Loops: Mechanisms for employees to safely share concerns and ideas, with demonstrated responsiveness from leadership.

Meaningful progress often involves qualitative changes as well: stories of employees feeling seen and valued, teams working more collaboratively, and a culture of openness taking shape.

Bringing in a DEI and workplace culture consultant is not a sign of failure, it’s a sign of commitment to your people and to the kind of organization you want to build. It signals that your organization is ready to take meaningful, strategic action and recognizes that sustainable change requires partnership, accountability, and expertise.

As an HR leader, your role is pivotal in creating an equitable, inclusive, and healthy workplace culture. Knowing when to seek external support and choosing the right consultant when you do, can accelerate your DEI goals while strengthening your team’s capacity to sustain progress for the long term.